Compare two investments

If I had put into or in , which would be worth more?

Apple

$474,526

from $1,000 put in, +$473,526 (+47,353%), +25.8% a year

Vanguard S&P 500

$8,896

from $1,000 put in, +$7,896 (+790%), +14.4% a year

Prices start in September 2010, so it's bought then.

Apple comes out $465,630 ahead.

How they grew

Apple would be worth $474,526 from $1,000 put in, and Vanguard S&P 500 $8,896 from $1,000, as of 16 Nov 2026. The year-by-year table below lists the same numbers.

Year by year

Value of Apple and Vanguard S&P 500 today and at the end of each year. The higher value each year is in bold.
YearAppleVanguard S&P 500
Today16 Nov 2026$474,526of $1,000$8,896of $1,000
2025$363,271of $1,000$8,146of $1,000
2024$324,739of $1,000$6,973of $1,000
2023$255,659of $1,000$5,522of $1,000
2022$171,574of $1,000$4,371of $1,000
2021$233,130of $1,000$5,342of $1,000
2020$173,140of $1,000$4,148of $1,000
2019$96,195of $1,000$3,511of $1,000
2018$47,240of $1,000$2,693of $1,000
2017$53,124of $1,000$2,794of $1,000
2016$35,783of $1,000$2,295of $1,000
2015$31,812of $1,000$2,046of $1,000
2014$32,489of $1,000$2,019of $1,000
2013$22,492of $1,000$1,770of $1,000
2012$21,374of $1,000$1,388of $1,000
2011$16,281of $1,000$1,164of $1,000
2010$12,967of $1,000$1,143of $1,000
2009$8,472of $1,000Not started yet
2008$3,648of $1,000Not started yet
2007$7,238of $1,000Not started yet
2006$3,411of $1,000Not started yet
2005$2,890of $1,000Not started yet
2004$1,294of $1,000Not started yet
2003$428of $1,000Not started yet
2002$299of $1,000Not started yet
2001$476of $1,000Not started yet
2000$299of $1,000Not started yet

How it works

Both investments get exactly the same money on the same dates. Each purchase buys at the first price on or after its date, and the shares are kept until today.

Prices are adjusted for stock splits and dividends, so dividends count as if they were reinvested. Taxes, fees and inflation are left out.

Whichever is worth more today comes out ahead.

Questions

How is the comparison fair?

Both investments get exactly the same money on exactly the same dates. The only difference is what that money bought, so the gap at the end comes from how the two investments did.

What if one of them didn't exist yet on my start date?

Then its first purchase happens on its first trading day, so it gets less time to grow and, with regular additions, fewer purchases. The money put in is shown under each number whenever it differs, so you can see the gap.

Was the winner always ahead?

Not necessarily. The year-by-year table shows what each would have been worth at the end of every year, so you can see if the lead changed hands. An investment that comes out ahead today can spend years behind.

Why is the gap so big when the yearly rates look close?

Growth compounds: each year's gain is added to everything before it. A few percentage points a year turn into a large difference after ten or twenty years.

Yearly returns

What's worth comparing?

Two companies in the same business, a single stock against an index fund like VOO, or two funds with different approaches, such as a broad market fund against a technology-heavy one like QQQ.