Compare two investment plans

If I had put into in ,or put into in ,which would be worth more today?

Apple

$28,704

from $1,000 put in, +$27,704 (+2,770%), +25.3% a year

Vanguard S&P 500

$56,822

from $17,900 put in, +$38,922 (+217%), +14.3% a year

Vanguard S&P 500 comes out $28,118 ahead. But Apple grew faster: +25.3% a year against +14.3% a year.

How they grew

Apple would be worth $28,704 from $1,000 put in, and Vanguard S&P 500 $56,822 from $17,900, as of 16 Nov 2026. The year-by-year table below lists the same numbers.

Year by year

Value of Apple and Vanguard S&P 500 today and at the end of each year. The higher value each year is in bold.
YearAppleVanguard S&P 500
Today16 Nov 2026$28,704of $1,000$56,822of $17,900
2025$22,043of $1,000$50,905of $16,800
2024$20,213of $1,000$42,063of $15,600
2023$15,465of $1,000$32,589of $14,400
2022$10,378of $1,000$24,720of $13,200
2021$14,102of $1,000$28,839of $12,000
2020$10,473of $1,000$21,323of $10,800
2019$5,745of $1,000$16,803of $9,600
2018$3,040of $1,000$11,750of $8,400
2017$3,213of $1,000$11,146of $7,200
2016$2,164of $1,000$8,056of $6,000
2015$1,924of $1,000$6,020of $4,800
2014$1,984of $1,000$4,750of $3,600
2013$1,411of $1,000$3,058of $2,400
2012$1,306of $1,000$1,263of $1,200

How it works

Each plan is worked out on its own: its money goes in on its own dates, buying at the first price on or after each date, and the shares are kept until today.

Prices are adjusted for stock splits and dividends, so dividends count as if they were reinvested. Taxes, fees and inflation are left out.

Ending with more money and growing faster aren't the same thing when the plans put in different amounts, so both are shown. The yearly rate accounts for when each dollar went in.

Questions

How is this different from Compare?

On Compare, both investments get the same money on the same dates. Here each plan has its own amount, start date and schedule, so you can test choices like starting earlier, putting in more, or buying monthly instead of all at once.

How can a plan end with more money but grow slower?

If it put in more money, it can end bigger even with a lower return. That's why both are shown: which plan ends with more, and which one grew each dollar faster. The yearly rate accounts for when each dollar went in.

Yearly returns

Can I compare investing all at once with buying every month?

Yes. Put an amount into the first plan once, and set the second plan to add a smaller amount every month from the same date. The monthly plan keeps adding until today, so it usually puts in more money overall. Look at the yearly rate as well as the final amount: it shows which plan grew each dollar faster.

Lump sum vs monthly

What does waiting a few years cost?

Pick the same investment for both plans with different start dates. The difference at the end is roughly what the later start missed out on, though it depends heavily on which years were skipped.